At the beginning of the year, I binged a 13-book series that was essentially the same book written 13 different ways. A human abducted by evil aliens, rescued by a good alien, they fall in love, and have to avoid the evil aliens until they find a safe home to settle down. So why was I still committed to each of the 13, even though I knew what would happen? Sometimes, when our real world is so unpredictable, escaping to a world where you know what to expect is a comfort.
Why Predictable Plots Get a Bad Rap?
You see it all the time in book reviews: predictable stories are labeled as unoriginal, relying too much on emotions, or are just recycling overdone tropes. Where the book world pushes for new and exciting, sometimes we readers crave reliability, satisfaction, and a sense of connection. “Predictable plots” are often said to be lazy writing. But depth is more than just a discovery; it also includes how it made the reader feel.
The Psychology of Familiarity
Why do readers, myself included, reach for books where we already know how it ends? It’s simple. Familiar story arcs soothe anxiety and provide emotional safety. In a world of uncertainty, a genre romance or classic fantasy lets us relax, knowing heartbreak will be mended or good will triumph.
Tips for Writers & Reviewers
To writers: I don’t want to tell you how to write, but don’t be afraid to embrace tropes. But keep emotional stakes fresh. Let your characters feel real pain, joy, and growth, even if it’s inside a familiar framework.
For reviewers: Frame your review to honor emotional impact and accessibility. You can even consider using a dual intimacy rating, one for plot innovation and another for emotional feeling. A predictable plot can score high on the feels.
Let’s celebrate the comforting books- the ones we return to, not despite their predictability, but because of it. What are your favorite “predictably perfect” reads? Sometimes the best stories are the ones we can see coming a mile away, but still love all the same.
Leave a Reply